Metal Roofing vs. Tile Roofing: How Do They Compare?

When deciding between a premier style of roofing, there is often one question on the minds of homeowners. “Which is better, metal roofing or tile roofing?” To answer that question, you really need to consider the benefits that each offers against the other and the overall difference in cost. To help better compare the two options, let’s look at the qualities of each.

Aesthetics and Design

There is no question that both metal and tile roofing styles are among the most attractive options available. Clay tile options have been around for centuries and so they are a proven option when it comes to durability and effectiveness. Tile roof can be visually appealing and offer a range of options when it comes to color and arrangement. Making it one of the most favored options when it comes to overall design.

Metal roofing does offer its own range of options in color and style, but probably not quite as many as tile roofing options. However, with advances in metal roofing styles and design, it has become a very popular option over the years.

The takeaway? They are both visually appealing, but very different in style.

Durability and Longevity

Both metal roofs and tile roofs are among the longest lasting and most durable forms of roofing. In fact, tile roofs can last upwards of 50 years or more in some cases with proper maintenance. Depending on the type of material used, metal roofs can also go quite the distance. Over 40 years in many cases.

With that being said, if you’re planning to replace your roof with either option, you shouldn’t have to do so again for a very long time. One of the biggest benefits to both metal and tile roofing is simply how long they last on a home.

The takeaway? Both are built to last.

Energy Efficiency

When it comes to energy efficiency, both metal and tile roofing rank among the best. Both offer unique advantages that help save on energy usage, while keeping your cooling and heating units running efficiently.

For instance, metal roofing is great at reflecting heat away from your home, keeping your home cooler and reducing strain on your AC unit. Likewise, tile roofing is ideal for insulation because air can more easily circulate throughout your roofing system.

The takeaway? Each option offers its own energy efficiency benefits.

Maintenance

All things considered, both metal and tile roofing require relatively low maintenance when compared to other roof types. Now this doesn’t mean no roof maintenance. It simply means that in general, these roof types are not as prone to serious damage as quickly as other roofs might endure.

But with that being said, it’s still a good idea to have your roof checked every 18 – 24 months for damage and other regular wear and tear.

The takeaway? Maintenance is minimal, but shouldn’t be ignored.

Cost

While both roof types are going to be more expensive than a standard asphalt shingle roof, tile roofs are generally more expensive than metal roofs. The primary reason being is not necessarily due to materials cost. Rather, it is because of the labor intensity and time needed to install these tile roofs. Whereas a metal roof may cost around $12 on the high end per square foot, a tile roof may be upwards of $20 per square foot in some cases.

The takeaway? Tile roofing is usually more costly because of the labor involved.

Which Roof Type is Right for You?

When it comes time to replace your roof, understandably, you want to select an option that not only looks great, but one that is going to last. Since metal roofing and tile roofing do come with their own unique set of advantages, the truth is, either is a solid option for a home.

But if you’re unsure what is best for you, we can help. We offer free estimates and can help in making a selection for your new roofing project. Contact us today to get started.